NIPSCO Gas wants to keep the millions it has overcharged customers in recent decades
In two cases before the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission (IURC), NIPSCO Gas wants to simultaneously dismantle much-needed energy efficiency programs and confiscate millions - and potentially even tens of millions - of dollars from gas customers who have been overcharged by its faulty gas meters for decades.
The Braun Administration's Office of Utility Consumer Counselor (OUCC) has negotiated awful settlements in two unrelated cases before the IURC - Cause Numbers 46329 and 46390. The settlements link these two cases together in a single deal that will further harm NIPSCO Gas customers who already struggle to pay their NIPSCO bills.
Cause Number 46329: NIPSCO admitted that it double-charged more than 6,800 gas customers over the last 20 to 50 years.
The customer impact thus far has amounted to thousands of dollars per affected customer, and potentially tens of thousands of dollars for many.
The settlement negotiated by the Braun Administration's OUCC allows NIPSCO to get away without a full investigation and only requires that affected customers be refunded for 2.5 years of the damage. That is an outrageous giveaway to NIPSCO at the expense of Hoosier families and businesses.
NIPSCO customers deserve a full and transparent investigation into NIPSCO’s wrongdoing, and customers who have been overcharged deserve full refunds, with interest. Gov. Braun has spoken loudly about utility affordability, so it is extremely disappointing to see his administration sweeping NIPSCO’s mismanagement under the rug.
Cause Number 46390: Gov. Braun allows the OUCC to propose dismantling the bulk of NIPSCO’s gas energy efficiency programs.
One of the best ways to bring about utility affordability is to create and sustain robust energy efficiency programs across the state. NIPSCO's gas energy efficiency programs pass rigorous cost-benefit tests - CAC knows this because we are on the oversight board for these programs.
The end result is lower bills for customers because efficiency reduces the amount of gas NIPSCO has to purchase and also reduces wear & tear on the system, which reduces maintenance costs. These programs collectively saved more than 5.1 million therms of natural gas in 2025 alone!
Allowing NIPSCO to kill these beneficial gas energy efficiency programs - like home rebates, energy audits, and efficiency programs for businesses and schools - adds insult to injury for NIPSCO gas customers. At a time when so many customers are struggling to afford our bills, this is going to drastically accelerate Indiana’s utility affordability crisis and is the wrong direction to take.





